Tuesday, January 20, 2009

Herland or Are There Any Women in Politics?

Hi, All

I enjoyed Herland and was a little surprised that it was so different from “The Yellow Wallpaper. ” Even though the two develop some of the same themes, most obviously gender roles and relationships, the novel has a sense of humor that the short story lacks. Gilman treats her subject with a bit of tongue in cheek humor, for example, when she nicknames Terry, Old Nick, and when Van’s full name is Vandyck.

I also enjoyed her puns: the initial flight of the biplane over Herland
is “way up at first, to get ‘the lay of the land’ and make note of it” (p. 10), and Van describes the three men as being “cocksure as to the inevitable limitation, the faults and vices, of a lot of women” (p. 81). This deft use of language gives a richness to the novel, especially since Gilman artfully and effortlessly works it into the prose.

I think this calm, understated style is also what makes the novel successful.
Gilman turns the male-dominated Victorian world on its head, but she does so using such a reasoned approach that the reader accepts her questioning of society.
One of the best examples is the conversation between the three men and their teachers about which women work and which ones stay at home taking care of children. When Moadine, Somel, and Zava figure out that one third of our women work because they are poor—and that these women have more children than the stay-at-home mothers, we begin to see the our way of life in a different light. Are we in reality a civilized, enlightened society?

As Bridgitte Arnold explains, “a reverse colonization occurs in Herland.…The male explorers are themselves colonized” (p. 306). Of course, this perception/questioning is influenced by the narrator of the story. Of three men, Van is the most receptive to the Herland way of life. By the end of the novel, he finds that he has a more fulfilling relationship with his wife than he imagined possible before his trip to this country of intelligent, strong, and competent women who defy socially constructed gender roles. The ending of Herland reminds me a little of the “Wife of Bath’s Tale.” Even though, according to the Hag, women want mastery in a relationship, she chooses to please her husband, suggesting that a good relationship is built on equality and caring, not on dominance.

The women of Herland also have a caring relationship with nature.
As Mary Jo Deegan and Christopher W. Podeschi point out, “Herland is a social and an environmental utopia….This valuation of nature is presented repeatedly, often couched in terms of aesthetics” (pp. 25 and 27). Realizing that their land is limited in size, the Herlanders voluntarily manage their population and their resources, respecting not only human life but plant and animal life also. Gilman appears to believe, like some ecofeminists, that women are closer to nature than men, perhaps because of their ability to give birth, this notion of motherhood playing a significant role in the novel. I wonder about this respect for nature, though. Does the fact that they replaced the trees in the forests with only food bearing ones suggest they manipulated nature for their benefit rather than valuing it for itself? Or is this an example of American pastoral as suggested by Garrard, one that emphasizes “a working rather than an aesthetic relationship with the land” (p. 49)?

I want to conclude with a reference to an interview yesterday on the Today show with Gwen Eifell about the inauguration of the first African-American President. One of ideas brought up was that there are no female African-American women of his age in politics, either on the state or the national level. First, I wonder: is this data true? Are there no young African-American women in politics? But then Eifell's response took me by surprise; she said that she thought it was a gender, not a race, phenomenon. Nancy Pelosi and Hiliary Clinton both did not enter politics until their children were grown (they chose motherhood, and women have more choices than men). Are these three assertions true? Neither of these women were in politics when their children were young? And futher, does our society esteem motherhood like the Herlanders? And if we do, what does that say, if anything, about the place of women in society? Are we to take Gilman's statements about motherhood seriously? Or is she again being tongue in cheek?

No comments:

Post a Comment