Hi, All,
The last time I read Brave New World, most of the students in this seminar probably had not yet been born. Although I remembered the basic ideas in it, I didn’t remember all of the particulars. I was hoping—or maybe expecting is a better word—a creative structure, given the content I remembered. And the last 10 pages of Chapter Three (pp. 47-56) met my expectations with their juxtaposition of multiple, seemingly unrelated conversations.
However, the rest of the novel was relatively linear in structure, and the conversation between the John and Mustapha in Chapter 17 even a bit didactic. So I reconsidered the structure to see what I had missed. The vacation trip to
John brings an appreciation of art and creativity with him to the Hatchery Centre as evidenced by his making of the clay pot on the mesa, for example. Helmholtz then realizes the power of art—and his inadequacy—when he tries his hand at propaganda verse, discovering that one has to be unhappy or to lack something to be a good artist. This theme of the importance and the role of the artist in society is an interesting inclusion in a novel dealing with role and effect of technology, especially since it becomes tied with the creativity involved in science when the Controller says “you’re making flivvers out of the absolute minimum of steel—works of art out of practically nothing but pure sensation.” (p. 221). Is Huxley suggesting that creation in science is the same as creativity in art?
Both Brave New World and “The Machine Stops” reflect Henri Lefebvre’s expanding the mental concept of space to include social spaces with his emphasis on its use in production. Both societies are a “hive . . .humming busily” (Huxley, p. 147). At the Hatchery Centre, the production involves the controlled creation of the population, with its conveyor belts, test tubes, monitors and chemicals as well as the other “advanced” aspects of the educational system and leisure activities. In this society no one is physically left alone, although some members, such as Bernard, are isolated by virtue of being different. The opposite is true in the short story by Forster: people are isolated and alone, communicating technologically with one another rather than face-to-face. Forster’s use of lectures reminds me of Clemson’s distant ed courses where we hold class virtually, not interacting physically in class discussion. Ironically, in the story, an “authority” could lecture on a topic, oceans for example, without ever having seen one.
Both works of literature include the theme of wilderness, and I see several connections with Garrard. One is based on its derivation from the Anglo-Saxon wilddeoren “where beasts existed beyond the boundaries of cultivation” (p. 60). The wilderness in the works exemplify this notion—being beyond the civilized or cultivated area of the society containing imagined fears in the case of the short story and the savages in the novel. Thus, a wilderness becomes “a threat…the place of exile” rather than a comforting setting (p. 61). This is fairly obvious in both works, but what I found more interesting in Garrard is the tie between the wilderness of nature with the “wilderness of the human body” (p. 67). Both societies also seem to fear the body—and its sensations: Vashti wants no contact with anyone, not even her son, and certainly no physical touching. In Huxley’s
I would like to make one last connection to something I heard on the news today. This report refers to the discussion during the colloquium about the use of advances in technology in cell biology and vision. Bioengineers have developed sensors to help people suffering from MS and strokes to improve their ability to walk. One woman with MS can now hike and jog—and she doesn’t have to use the sensors all of the time any longer. It seems that her body has repaired (dare I say rejuvenated) itself.
